About Kesher Talk

  • "Kesher" means "connection" in Hebrew. The banner image is the mosaic floor of a 6th c. synagogue in Jericho, showing a menorah flanked by a shofar and lulav; the inscription reads "Shalom Al Yisrael." (This synagogue was destroyed by Arab vandals a few years ago. The condition of the mosaic floor is unknown.)
  • Contributors:
  • Judith Weiss
    admin-at-keshertalk-dot-com
  • Van Wallach
    mission76tx-at-yahoo-dot-com


« Further evidence of liberal slant on campus | Home | Carnival of the Protestors, the evening after »

August 30, 2004

Carnival of the Protestors, the morning after

Previous Carnival of the Protestors entries here, here, and here.

Glenn has some links to protest coverage with photos.
Allah is continuing to provide lots of links. (Thanks for the mention, O Omnipresent One.)

Shawn Macomber notes an irony:

The catch phrase of the day was, "Dissent is Patriotic." I saw not a hint of irony on the faces of the mob as they demanded, for hours on end, "Republicans go home!" and "GOP scum, leave our city!"

Let's think about this for a moment: There are 5,000 Republican delegates in town for the convention. Protest organizers predict the final count will be somewhere around 250,000 and I've no reason to doubt the figure. So protesters will outnumber delegates 50 to one. At what point exactly, I asked several members of the Question Authority Brigade, is one group far enough in the minority that they become, well, dissenters? Sputtering, uncomprehending rage was all I got in response. But considering the numbers and the fact that any small Republican counter-protest was immediately converged upon on by frothing-mouthed burst of vitriol and obscenity, it would seem those speaking truth to power (i.e., "dissenters") in New York City Sunday morning were Republicans.

. . . "This is what democracy looks like!" the crowd chants as they demand that Republicans' right to assembly and speech be beaten to a bloody pulp.

He has many more examples - read the whole thing.

Protest Warrior gets more press:

We passed a group of counter-protesters from the group protestwarrior.com, who were holding up signs mocking the protesters: "World Workers Party...the last thing we do is work." A guy just ahead of us in the march was covered in green make-up to look like the statue of liberty and was wearing just a robe, with a skeletal, scary-looking set of teeth painted on his face and � for some reason � a little flower in his ear. By any standard, this guy was dressed like a freak. But he stopped us to ask, in scandalized and mystified tones, of the counter-protesters, "Who were those people?"

Another man was arrested at Broadway and 34th Street after he assaulted a member of the Republican counterprotest group, Protest Warriors, known for its humorous signs that mock the leftist agenda. A protester wearing an anti-Bush T-shirt attempted to grab a sign held by a Protest Warrior, then took a swing at the pro-Bush activist who was standing along the parade route. As he was being carried away by police, the anti-Bush protester said, "They're not one of us, they're making us look bad."

Awww, poor baby . . .
Tom Paladino, who heads the New York chapter of Protest Warriors, said several members of his group were assaulted and shouted down when they tried to join the anti-Bush march. "We've marched in other rallies and we've had some hard times, but this one was just too dicey," Mr. Paladino said. He said that one anti-Bush protester grabbed a megaphone from his hands and smashed it on the street, and that at least 20 of his group's signs were destroyed by the protesters. He promised, though, that group members will continue to show up at the major anti-Bush rallies scheduled throughout the week.
For example:
The group that organized Sunday's enormous demonstration, United for Peace and Justice, found its headquarters a target of protest on Monday _ by pro-Bush demonstrators from a group called ProtestWarrior. About 15 members, chanting "Four more years!" and "USA! USA!", targeted the anti-Bush group. "They like protests so much. They're about to get a taste of their own medicine," said ProtestWarrior co-founder Alan Lipton of Austin, Texas.
Deep within the bowels of MSG, Roger chats with Ed Koch, another liberal Jewish Democrat for Bush.
Tacitus is there too.

As he did for the Democratic convention, Tim Blair is blogging from the Republican convention for Reason. So is Julian Sanchez, who spots the Libertarian candidate for president in Central Park.

Cox & Forkum.

VP Cheney kicks off the convention from Ellis Island (where my dad entered the US in 1944, at the age of 17).

Still fighting a cold, I'm off to meet up with Eric and Mary at a book event. (Wish Mary a happy birthday!)

Next installment here.

Judith | 08/30/04 at 12:32 PM | Categories: - Useful idiots

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.keshertalk.com/cgi-bin/mtb.cgi/3333

Comments

I hate to burst your sputtering rage at the protesters, folks, but the idiots you hold up as being emblematic of the entire several-hundred-thousand-strong protest march are just that, the predictable number of idiots you'll find in any large gathering. Do you seriously think that if perhaps a half-million right-wing Americans gathered, there wouldn't be some hateful signs, some shouts of bile, and some minor arrests?

I covered Sunday's event for a news agency (which is why I'm posting anonymously), and watched group after group walk by for hours. Most were ordinary people, not the frothing activists some Bush supporters wish their opponents were -- they could have been your co-workers, your relatives, your neighbors. They held signs with clever anti-Bush puns, or wince-inducing ones. They banged drums, they held up banners and shouted whenever media helicopters went overhead, and they stayed basically orderly and focused despite a hot, muggy day.

I chatted with several cops, and what kept them busiest was trying to shepherd people across the street when the required gaps in the march got too narrow. The police were hot, and resentful of being dragged from all five boroughs to work all day at the march and then most of the overnight hours during the final stages of convention setup. Despite that, they and the protesters were both largely respectful of each other. Even the head of the NYC police said as much.

The march had some powerful moments alongside the garden-variety anti-Bush cheerleading. When 1,000 coffins were carried past to remind viewers of the lives lost in Iraq, even people who supported the war, like the cop I was then talking with, felt it made a dramatic point that Americans seem quick to forget the many young soldiers dying over there.

I know it's easy to write off those you wish to ignore as an unruly mob, but as a neutral (though very pro-Israel) observer, I can tell you that you'd be wrong in this case to demonize those who dissent.

Anonymous | August 30, 2004 06:42 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style and URL links.
My spam filter rejects any word containing "sex" and "poker" - use asterisks like so: "p*ker")

CURRENT MOON
lunar phases