« The Jewish Carnival of the Protestors | Home | Arrival Day Blogburst »
September 08, 2004
Political SIGs
Someone on some comment thread a few months ago (I don't have a link for this; it just stuck in my mind) advanced the idea that much of the Michael Moore-ish rabidness of liberal politics these days comes from techie nerds who are just starting to participate in mainstream politics. They made lots of money in the 90s, got laid off in the bust, and now have time on their hands, so they jump into politics. But they are very ignorant. But they are rich techie nerds so they don't know they are ignorant, and they are full of opinions and ready to inflict them on everyone. And they increase the flamishness of political discourse because that's how they are used to talking anyway.So tell me, Gen X readers, does this have a ring of truth? Any evidence?
UPDATE: Eric takes the ball and runs with it.
Judith | 09/08/04 at 05:54 PM | Categories: - GOTV '04
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.keshertalk.com/cgi-bin/mtb.cgi/3358
Comments
I think MoveOn.org and the Howard Dean campaign may have had a lot to do with that lefty-techie image. It would be interesting to look at the demographics of the nerd sector.
BTW, thanks for the link!
shoshanna | September 8, 2004 10:38 PM
From my experience int he tech field for the past decade (as a software engineer) most technical people are very socially liberal and pretty libertarian on economic/war and peace issues, but still, political opinions are all over the map. About the only demographic that is really under-represented in the tech world is the religious right.
Mike | September 9, 2004 12:37 PM
As a silicon valley refugee, I agree with Mike. Techie political opinions are all over the map.
There were even some who had very strong religious beliefs. Our web team manager was a somewhat right-leaning Jewish man who, despite his alpha-geek ability to write programs in vi, had a very traditional manner.
A lot of liberal/libertarian hawks started blogging after 9/11, to express opinions, and sometimes, anger. A lot of left-leaning types started blogging after the war in Iraq started, expressing their opinions and anger. The lefties might be more prominent now because they have more issues.
In any case, as we saw with the questionable authenticity of the Bush memo, when it comes to genuine fact-checking, techies with time on their hands can be a good thing.
mary
Anonymous | September 10, 2004 04:28 PM
My perspective is pretty different. I was frustrated for a decade with my techie peers, who had the competence to build a large-scale systems and/or start businesses, yet had a technolibertarian, apathetic, or despairing attitude about participating as citizens.
The areas where techies can have the most difference as a group is in tech-related policy, which was suffering from the lack of informed, active citizens. The INDUCE act faced much more opposition than the DMCA, because techies have woken up.
There was some truth to the naivete of the Dean-tech crew, but that naivete is short lived -- people learn. I know people in Austin, Chicago, Minneapolis, and the Bay area -- just personal contacts -- who started as Dean supporters, and have matured into taking larger more traditional precinct-based roles in reviving moribund Democratic party organization at the local level.
This energy is a good thing. In recent decades, right-wing conservatives have had a grassroots organizing advantage through church communities, when large numbers of moderate Americans had forgotten how to organize and were largely apathetic.
Shana Tovah, Adina
Adina | September 19, 2004 06:54 PM
Hi Adina,
Did you know your GreaterDemocracy.org friends are part of the "web of connections" around Rathergate?
Shana tova,
Judith
Judith | September 20, 2004 02:05 AM


![[TypeKey Profile Page]](http://www.keshertalk.com/nav-commenters.gif)











