« Mikolot mayim rabim adirim mishberay yam | Home | Revealing Conversation »
September 04, 2005
Hurricane-based finger-pointing
After many links to relief organizations and spiritual ruminations, it's time to join Junkyard Blog in decisively refuting the campaign to blame the Bush Aministration while making excuses for the ineptitude of local and state officials.
Throughout the Labor Day weekend, some people have been coordinating and linking to relief efforts (but read the comments), and some have been using the tragedy to pile on the snark. As Am I a Pundit Now says:
[ UPDATE on local/state/fed chain-of-command issues, with no clear answers.
Gov. Blanco finally authorized school buses to be used for evacuation. On Sept 1st.
Eye-opening National Guard briefing on restoring order in the Superdome.]
As the waters begin to recede, the facts emerge:
Remember that the vulnerability of New Orleans has been known for decades, while you read this:
Behind the scenes, a power struggle emerged, as federal officials tried to wrest authority from Louisiana Gov. Kathleen Babineaux Blanco (D). Shortly before midnight Friday, the Bush administration sent her a proposed legal memorandum asking her to request a federal takeover of the evacuation of New Orleans, a source within the state's emergency operations center said Saturday.Why am I not surprised that this is all about turf? Louisiana's medieval standards of governance are legendary. A commenter at Chrenkoff points out the difference between the respective leaderships of Louisiana and Mississippi, which sustained more damage but was managed more competently, and concludes:
The administration sought unified control over all local police and state National Guard units reporting to the governor. Louisiana officials rejected the request after talks throughout the night, concerned that such a move would be comparable to a federal declaration of martial law. Some officials in the state suspected a political motive behind the request. "Quite frankly, if they'd been able to pull off taking it away from the locals, they then could have blamed everything on the locals," said the source, who does not have the authority to speak publicly.
This was a good reminder that LA has for decades been our worst managed and most corrupt state. . . . the South has been booming for the past 25 or so years. The major cities went from backwater jokes to leading cities - Atlanta, Raleigh, Dallas, all of Florida, etc. The "hole in the map" in all of this has been Louisiana - it's like the last 25 or 30 years of southern growth have passed it right by. Get away from the gussified tourist areas and NO is a pretty awful city.
A comment at LGF:
I sat in on a discussion with a senior National Guard officer from one of the southeast states just the other day. He, and other senior Guardsman in the region, are appalled by the foot-dragging in Louisiana. The Gulf Coast states have been dealing with hurricanes for some time, and have things down pretty pat. They have state-to-state agreements to help each other out, way before the Feds need to get involved.
More examples of lethargy and incompetence from New Orleans bureaucracy. More from Captain Ed:
When the storm reached Cat-5 status in the Gulf of Mexico, what did George Bush do? He declared the entire Gulf coast an emergency area and mobilized FEMA. Until it actually made landfall, however, he could not pinpoint the assets. . . . The city of New Orleans and the state of Louisiana asked people to evacuate, but made no preparations to assist people in that endeavor. By Friday the outbound roads clogged with people in cars looking to escape, which all did. However, an entire fleet of school buses -- hundreds of them -- sat in their parking lots, gathering dust. Until George Bush called Governor Blanco personally and pleaded with her to make the evacuation order mandatory on Saturday, neither Mayor Nagin nor Blanco told people they had to leave. Apparently, that order only went out over the TV and radio from their press conference; no attempt was made to direct people out of their homes and onto the road.
Bill Hobbs has more on the unused buses:
. . . the New Orleans Regional Transportation Authority operated at least 364 buses . . . If each bus could hold just 60 people, NORTA's 364 buses had the capacity to take almost 22,000 peope out of harm's way per trip. Given that Nagin ordered the compulsory evacuation of the city two days before the storm hit, there was sufficient time for more than one trip - sufficient time to move tens of thousands of the city's poorest residents out of New Orleans by bus before Katrina arrived. . . . A commenter notes that the New Orleans Public School system also had buses - hundreds of them. Why weren't they pressed into service to evacuate the thousands of residents who had no way out?Apparently Mayor Nagin didn't know they were there.
Pundit Guy notes that the National Guard troops expected to provide disaster relief, augmenting a functioning police force. They didn't expect to be shot at by looters. From DefenseLink:
Army Lt. Gen. H Steven Blum said the Guard forces aren’t simply troops with no police skills pulled into the mission; they’re bringing solid expertise to the mission and an understanding that they’re supporting existing law enforcement authorities, not replacing them. . . .The Posse Comitatus Act prohibits active-duty forces from conducting law enforcement operations, but does not cover National Guard members operating under their state governors’ control. This enables Guard forces, who often come from the communities they are serving, to work side by side with law enforcement officials in ways active-duty forces simply can’t.
(More on the purpose of the National Guard.)
Tomorrow's forecast: Hysteria continues.
UPDATE: A good point:
. . . it's becoming increasingly less obvious that more first responders etc, would have made an enormous difference in the aftermath of this unfolding calamity. The disaster zone after 9/11 was less than 40 square blocks. Rescue vehicles shot straight down Broadway, Fifth Avenue, the West Side Highway etc. The disaster zone, as the President mentioned, is the size of Great Britain. Would relief vehicles have made it to the center of Ground Zero on 9/11 immediately if the rim of the disaster area was deep inside New England? All of the truly damnable mistakes were made before Katrina hit land. Why weren't more people evacuated? for example. Such mistakes are legion and fall disproportionately at the state and local level.
UPDATE: The logistics of relief: Jason posts an email about trucks into NO and asks:
Think the shortage of available fuel for 300 miles might put a crimp on any Federal response?
Judith | 09/04/05 at 12:43 AM | Categories: Natural disasters
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.keshertalk.com/cgi-bin/mtb.cgi/3977
Blogs which link to Hurricane-based finger-pointing:
» More Unused Buses from BillHobbs.com
Junkyard Blog is looking at high-res satellite photos of flooded New Orleans and finding more buses that Mayor Ray Nagin failed to use to evacuate the city's tens of thousands of poor residents before Hurricane Katrina hit, costing perhaps thousands of... [Read More]
Tracked on September 4, 2005 06:17 PM
» Katrina Sweeps Week from Kesher Talk
On the anniversary of Hurricane Katrina, let us remember . . . . All the reasons why Katrina was a disaster waiting to happen, which could only be partially mitigated by any governmental action. The beginnings of federal, state... [Read More]
Tracked on August 30, 2006 11:08 PM
Comments
Nice S.T.F.U. logo!
Josia | September 4, 2005 02:58 PM
The STFU logo should be modified to cover almost every important subject.
Attila (Pillage Idiot) | September 4, 2005 09:48 PM
Ken Says: I hereby place this image into the public domain - please copy it and distribute it liberally.
Yehudit | September 4, 2005 10:05 PM
What I have learned from the appalling display of inept local NOLA leadership for not having secured the area immediately is the life-saving necessity for NY'ers to have easier access to obtaining a gun permit.
If I cannot obtain the necessary means to be able to protect myself in times of disaster, I am positive I will move out of NY State, taking my tax dollars with me.
Considering the appalling leadership shown by RINO Mayor Bloomberg over the years, I know that he will most likely impose political correctness whereby leaving us innocent defendless citzens in harms way.
What I know is that in order to recieve protection from local NYC government I am going to have to behave like an anarchist, anti-American, Republican hater.
susan | September 5, 2005 08:18 AM
I believe there needs to be a two-pronged approach. Do what you can to help those in need and spread the word about what NOLA and LA officials lack of carrying out procedure.
Andrew Ian Dodge | September 5, 2005 07:19 PM
President Bush had his press secretary provide us with a new phrase, “Blame Game.”
It was introduced at a press conference where it was repeated eight times.
In order to ensure that ‘No Child Is Left Behind’ (unlike the thousands of children left behind to drown in the Gulf Coast) here is a word game you can play with your children so that they can know and use the phrase.
First of all the purpose of the exercise is to ensure that children and you, as an adult, are able to repeat the phrase when it is needed.
As part of our Homeland Defense it should be repeated eight times whenever anyone says something like this, ‘Undersecretary of FEMA Michael D. Brown is apparently an incompetent whose inadequate preparations led to the needless death of thousands of Americans, the destruction of several towns and the loss of one American city.’
As soon as you hear something like that you should say, ‘Blame Game, Blame Game, Blame Game, Blame Game, Blame Game, Blame Game, Blame Game, Blame Game.’
Children should look at the ground and shuffle their feet.
Responsible bureaucrats would also like us all to practice this other word game.
When anyone says, ‘Michael D. Brown should be fired.’, you respond, ‘Why would I do that for?’
For full effect repeat, ‘Blame Game, Blame Game, Blame Game, Blame Game, Blame Game, Blame Game, Blame Game, Blame Game.’
Hopefully these instructions will be available soon on FEMA for kids :
http://www.fema.gov/kids/index.htm
cranston36 | September 8, 2005 04:03 PM


![[TypeKey Profile Page]](http://www.keshertalk.com/nav-commenters.gif)












