« Merry Christmas | Home | Miracle on 47th Street: A Heartwarming Holiday Encounter »
December 25, 2005
Thanking The Military
A nice tale for Christmas about thanking those who sacrifice in the military from the LATimes.
In order to thank the military, it helps to understand military culture. And you won't get much of that from the mainstream press these days, except for fare which seems to register only as lip-service.
Which makes it even more surprising to find this piece in the LATimes, from Robert D. Kaplan of the troops on the ground in Iraq.
IF YOU WANT to meet the future political leaders of the United States, go to Iraq. I am not referring to the generals, or even the colonels. I mean the junior officers and enlistees in their 20s and 30s. In the decades ahead, they will represent something uncommon in U.S. military history: war veterans with practical experience in democratic governance, learned under the most challenging of conditions.
For several weeks, I observed these young officers working behind the scenes to organize the election in Mosul, Iraq's second-largest city. They arranged for the sniffer dogs at the polling stations and security for the ballots right up to the moment Iraqi officials counted them. They arranged the outer ring of U.S. military security, with inner ones of Iraqi soldiers and police at each polling station, even as they were careful to give the Iraqis credit for what they, in fact, were doing. The massive logistical exercise of holding an election in a city of 2.1 million people was further complicated by the fact that the location of many polling stations changed at the last minute to prevent terrorist attacks. Throughout Iraq, young Army and Marine captains have become veritable mayors of micro-regions, meeting with local sheiks, setting up waste-removal programs to employ young men, dealing with complaints about cuts in electricity and so on. They have learned to arbitrate tribal politics, to speak articulately and to sit through endless speeches without losing patience.I watched Lt. John Turner of Indianapolis get up on his knees from a carpet while sipping tea with a former neighborhood mukhtar and plead softly: "Sir, I am willing to die for a country that is not my own. So will you resume your position as mukhtar? Brave men must stand forward. Iraq's wealth is not oil but its civilization. Trust me by the projects I bring, not by my words."
Turner, a D student in high school, got straightened out as an enlisted man in the Coast Guard before earning a degree from Purdue and becoming an Army officer. He is one of what Col. Michael Shields, commander of the 172nd Stryker Brigade Combat Team in Mosul, calls his "young soldier-statesmen."
Throughout Iraq, young Army and Marine captains have become veritable mayors of micro-regions, meeting with local sheiks, setting up waste-removal programs to employ young men, dealing with complaints about cuts in electricity and so on. They have learned to arbitrate tribal politics, to speak articulately and to sit through endless speeches without losing patience.
I watched Lt. John Turner of Indianapolis get up on his knees from a carpet while sipping tea with a former neighborhood mukhtar and plead softly: "Sir, I am willing to die for a country that is not my own. So will you resume your position as mukhtar? Brave men must stand forward. Iraq's wealth is not oil but its civilization. Trust me by the projects I bring, not by my words."
Turner, a D student in high school, got straightened out as an enlisted man in the Coast Guard before earning a degree from Purdue and becoming an Army officer. He is one of what Col. Michael Shields, commander of the 172nd Stryker Brigade Combat Team in Mosul, calls his "young soldier-statesmen."
And while we are on the subject of Robert Kaplan, The American Enterprise has a fantastic interview with him, "Live with TAE: Robert Kaplan" up in the January/February edition of its online journal, Whatever Happened to Small Government? about his impressions of the current military gained by living in close proximity to them.
In fact, the interview is so good, I just bought Kaplan's book: Imperial Grunts
Hat Tip: Seraphic Secret
Alcibiades | 12/25/05 at 12:38 PM | Categories: - Nation-building
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.keshertalk.com/cgi-bin/mtb.cgi/4390
Blogs which link to Thanking The Military:
» Robert Kaplan Redux from Kesher Talk
Glenn points to the transcript of Hugh Hewitt's interview with Robert Kaplan, earlier today. Like all the Kaplan links I've seen this week, it's another fascinating read. Earlier in the week I posted some Kaplan links here. This link in... [Read More]
Tracked on December 29, 2005 01:37 AM
Comments
Yes. And not only the future political leaders, but also the future business leaders.
Anyone who is hiring people, with an eye toward long-term contributors to their company, needs to be seriously thinking about Iraq and Afghanistan veterans. What does one concievably learn in b-school about leadership that compares with the kind of experiencs mentioned in Kaplan's article.
David Foster | December 25, 2005 12:56 PM
Let us not forget Kaplan's prediction was fulfilled a century ago in the person of WILLIAM HOWARD TAFT, the only person to become US President and Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. As the first civilian governor of the first and only colony America ever had, he led several generations of Americans in an experiment to establish Democracy on the other side of the world, who would indeed rise to become America's leaders: soldiers, teachers, scientists, civil administrators, the architects of a nation still on the long road to Freedom. And there is much to learn in the 1912 elections, which I believe may find some echoes in the coming 2008 contest.
Rizalist | December 25, 2005 06:15 PM
I saw that at Barnes and Noble when it first came out, but unfortunately I didn't have enough money at the time. I think I'll order it through interlibrary loan. Another book that I really enjoyed about the Special Forces/Green Berets is "Masters of Chaos" by Linda Robinson. Those guys are unbelievable, and Ms Robinson was given unheard of access to them.
Maggie
| December 25, 2005 07:11 PM













