About Kesher Talk

  • "Kesher" means "connection" in Hebrew. The banner image is the mosaic floor of a 6th c. synagogue in Jericho, showing a menorah flanked by a shofar and lulav; the inscription reads "Shalom Al Yisrael." (This synagogue was destroyed by Arab vandals a few years ago. The condition of the mosaic floor is unknown.)
  • Contributors:
  • Judith Weiss
    admin-at-keshertalk-dot-com
  • Van Wallach
    mission76tx-at-yahoo-dot-com


« Thoughts on Sharon's Health and Political Legacy | Home | The coming showdown with Iran »

January 05, 2006

After Sharon?

[ UPDATE: Multimedia on Sharon and his legacy at MSNBC. More updates throughout the day, scroll down.]

I got to see Sharon speak when he came to NYC last spring to campaign for the disengagement among American Jews. He got a mixed reception.

Sometimes a divisive public figure can unite people in death, who would be at each other's throats while he was alive. Sometimes they unite to back his successor. Meryl says that this is Olmert's Harry Truman moment, and read the comments too. And she links to this profile of Ehud Olmert.

Daniel Pipes is pessimistic about Kadima, but he was against disengagement, so he views the probably ascendancy of Likud favorably.


Soccer Dad critiques Sharon's government
for failing to seek widespread support for his policies, or planning for his succession.

Omri Ceren - whose updates on Sharon's condition were very appreciated - moves to analysis of what to expect in Israel's political scene as power moves from Sharon to . . . . who? He evaluates the possibilities for each of Israel's major political parties. Apropos of Meryl's comments above, he thinks Kadima's survival depends on

Olmert's ability to (a) become powerful very, very quickly and (b) get the party to somehow officially designate him as its leader very, very quickly. Odds that either of those things will happen are difficult to determine - for instance, nobody knows how or where Kadima would hold primaries (or who would vote in them). There are a lot of really talented politicians who have risked their political careers on Kadima, and they probably can't go back to their old parties (Peretz was already stacking Labor with his union friends before Kadima existed, while everyone knows [Netanyahu] to be vindictive and petty). So there are a lot of really big brains with an incentive to make Kadima work.

. . . Olmert has three months to prove that he's able to lead the country. But he has to act quickly to demonstrate that he's even going to be running as a leader of anything.


A caption contest from happier days.

UPDATES: Meyrav Wurmser in National Review thinks Kadima was an anomaly created by Sharon's outsized influence on Israeli politics, which is better off without it.

Also Joel Rosenberg on Bibi's chances:

All but written off by many political observers in Israel who thought he would be trounced in a three-way battle with Sharon, the former Prime Minister could be Israel's next Prime Minister. He won the recent Likud primaries decisively. He has taken a tough position on Iran. And he has a track-record of controlling Palestinian terrorism while also negotiating peace deals (he gave Hebron to Yasser Arafat, though the Israeli Left never gave him much credit and the Right was furious). But Netanyahu's success is by no means certain. His party is badly divided. The Israeli press hates him. And he would need to find a way to win over centrists while not causing the Right to abandon him. It won't be easy. But suddenly, it's possible.

Boker Tov, Boulder contrasts some Israeli and Palestinian reactions to Sharon's illness, but Palestinian reactions - at least at the official level - are more complex:
U.S. National Security Council official Elliott Abrams and State Department official David Welch were to have met with Sharon on Thursday evening, apparently to urge Israel to reverse a decision to ban Palestinian voting in disputed Jerusalem. . . . Abbas has said he may not hold elections if Jerusalem, chttp://www.keshertalk.com/cgi-bin/mt.cgi?__mode=view&ping_errors=1&_type=entry&id=5457&blog_id=1&saved_changes=1laimed by the Palestinians as a capital, is excluded. “We hope that this (Sharon’s illness) will not affect what we had expected of the Israelis,” said Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat. If Olmert puts off a decision on Jerusalem, “it means the Palestinian election is going down,” Erekat said.

. . . . Arab TV broadcasters beamed out largely straightforward, nonstop live coverage about Sharon.
Ahmed Jibril, a radical Palestinian leader in Damascus, Syria, called the stroke a gift from God.
. . . . But a Palestinian commentator on the Saudi-owned Al-Arabiya network offered Sharon unexpected praise as “the first Israeli leader who stopped claiming Israel had a right to all of the Palestinians’ land,” a reference to Israel’s Gaza withdrawal. “A live Sharon is better for the Palestinians now, despite all the crimes he has committed against us,” said Ghazi al-Saadi.


The nutcase running Iran sees Sharon's illness as another opportunity to posture. (via Meryl, doing her own update)

Comment from Winds of Change:

IMO this means that Israel won't attack Iran. All politics is local. The Israelis will have to settle their differences over Sharon's replacement before a successor will be strong enough to do anything risky aboard. Even if means being nuked in the meantime.

So it's up to us.

Judith | 01/05/06 at 12:38 PM | Categories: Eretz Yisrael

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.keshertalk.com/cgi-bin/mtb.cgi/4442

Blogs which link to After Sharon?:

» Passing of a Generation from Fightin' with Grabes
... And Yehudit, or Judith Weiss, editor of Kesher Talk, writes this comprehensive portal-post for the typically impressive Winds of Change. Keep checking it. [Read More]

Tracked on January 5, 2006 09:10 PM

Comments

Judith,
Pipes might view Netanyahu more favorably than Sharon right now, but he hasn't been a big fan.
http://www.danielpipes.org/article/309
In all likelihood Pipes views Netanyahu as the best candidate right now; not as a particularly strong one overall.

soccerdad [TypeKey Profile Page] | January 5, 2006 02:03 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style and URL links.
My spam filter rejects any word containing "sex" and "poker" - use asterisks like so: "p*ker")

CURRENT MOON
lunar phases