« Munich massacre cont. | Home | Site design bleg »
January 02, 2006
More Gazan Illogic
[ Updates at end ]
Even British officials recognize something bizarre about Ms. Burton's post kidnapped behavior:
Ms Burton was extremely reluctant to give any descriptions of her captors. “Kate had long ideological discussions with the kidnappers which certainly tired her out,” one official said, “but we have been trying to impress on her that it was serious and that she was kidnapped.”Makes me wonder whose "ideology" was purer. And which of them wasn't hewing sufficiently to the party line?
I'm fairly sure the former must have been Kate. Geez, her kidnappers probably wanted something as ideologically unnecessary as monetary benefit for themselves or their mates. How lowering for them to have their lack of purity pointed out by her.
Since Kate admits she knew where she was being held, I continue to wonder did she know them - even vaguely - or recognize them. Why won't she give a description. Despite being a kidnap victim, does she consider herself a neutral party in all this?
The Daily Mail gives one explanation, in a piece not online:
Her aunt, Wendy Hagenbuch, told the Mail last night: ‘Kate will be very forgiving of these men because she believes they wouldn’t do this sort of thing without good reason. She has a very sympathetic nature’.Kidnappers, of course, are known for always acting from good reason.
UPDATE: Melanie Phillips, backs from hiatus, adds more, pointing to the website where Kate Burton does her "very important work", which presents all violence in the area as initiated by Israel, the vile oppresser, while Palestinians actions are whitewashed. Palestinian suicide bombs are "protests, etc.
Phillips highlights the charitable mindset of the extended Burton family, and then points out how this very British decency becomes upended on the subject of Israel.
This is what is so distressing about what has happened to Britain. Nice people now turn out to have monstrous views. Decency itself has been kidnapped and brainwashed and turned into a diabolical mirror image of itself. The moment you meet one of these liberal, tolerant, well-educated, well-spoken, well-mannered, internationalist-minded folk for whom the third world is a synonym for global injustice, you know that they are going to despise or hate Israel and bestow their compassion on the promoters of genocide. One constantly meets such people who have compassion for the vulnerable and want to do good in the world: pillars of the community, admirable and delightful in every way — except that they side with people who happen to have a murderous hatred of Israel and the Jews.
UPDATE II: And even more wisdom from Ms. Burton in the BBC:
They said they had carried out the kidnappings to highlight issues such as Palestinian prisoners being held in Israeli jails.Didn't we always know that this would somehow be the fault of the Israelies!? Imagine! The injustice of putting Palestinians in prison for terrorism and murder.She said she believed they would have used a different tactic if they felt they could.
"I got the feeling that there was a real sadness in the kidnappers' hearts that they needed to do this."
UPDATE III:
The kidnapping had made [Kate] "love the Palestinian people even more," she said, adding that the majority were peace-loving and disapproved of violence.
Alcibiades | 01/02/06 at 12:25 PM | Categories: Eretz Yisrael
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.keshertalk.com/cgi-bin/mtb.cgi/4429
Blogs which link to More Gazan Illogic:
» The positive side of the Palestinians from Kesher Talk
One more bit on preening kidnap "victim" Kate Burton (via Bloghead): I was aware there was a risk and still took the chances and put my parents at risk. In retrospect I think I shouldn't have done that, but I... [Read More]
Tracked on January 3, 2006 09:32 AM
Comments
You're also in the "Best Politics" category, giving you 8 nominations...
Ezzie | January 2, 2006 02:55 PM
As I posited, and posted, elsewhere, I think there was some degree of complicity on Ms. Burton's part.
Translation into plain English: There was no kidnapping, it was all staged.
emanon | January 2, 2006 04:39 PM
As I suggested below, I don't consider that outside of the realm of possibility, but without some proof, one way or the other, I don't want to state it more definitively than that.
Plus, I do hesitate at the fact that Ms. Burton was accompanied in her kidnapping by her 70 year old father. She'd have to be quite hardened to make him undergo that.
alcibiades | January 2, 2006 05:04 PM
It's an old story. Google "Giangiacomo Feltrinelli" for a different and more extreme but but related example. This article is interesting.
Just another masochistic poster child for the suicide of the West.
Joe Katzman | January 3, 2006 10:19 AM


![[TypeKey Profile Page]](http://www.keshertalk.com/nav-commenters.gif)











