« San Francisco rally for Denmark | Home | War Poetry Contest »
March 11, 2006
A tale of two towns

First, the timidity of Valencia, Spain:
In the Fallas festival, giant sculptures of the high and mighty are placed in the streets for the public to mock before being destroyed in an orgy of gunpowder and flames. It has survived attacks by the Roman Catholic church, various puritanical rulers and the Franco dictatorship.. . . .Valencians watched global protests against newspaper cartoons of Mohammed with growing alarm. Last month, the mayor, Rita Barberá, urged artists to "temper freedom with a sense of responsibility" when referring to religious subjects. At least one well known local Fallas artist admitted to removing elements from his display of comic sculptures. . . . that identified them as Arabs.
Félix Crespo, the senior official in charge of the Central Fallas Council that runs the festival, urged the neighbourhood committees that raise funds to build the sculptures to avoid mixing humour with religion, "because that can be misunderstood".
Everyone assumed these warnings referred to Islam because sculptures of Roman Catholic priests, nuns, even of God, are a central part of the Fallas.[emphasis mine]
Contrast with the confidence of Saint-Genis-Pouilly, France:
A municipal cultural center here on France's border with Switzerland organized a reading of a 265-year-old play by Voltaire, whose writings helped lay the foundations of modern Europe's commitment to secularism. The play, "Fanaticism, or Mahomet the Prophet," uses the founder of Islam to lampoon all forms of religious frenzy and intolerance.The production quickly stirred up passions that echoed the cartoon uproar. "This play . . . constitutes an insult to the entire Muslim community," said a letter to the mayor of Saint-Genis-Pouilly, signed by Said Akhrouf, a French-born cafe owner of Moroccan descent and three other Islamic activists representing Muslim associations. They demanded the performance be cancelled.
Instead, Mayor Hubert Bertrand called in police reinforcements to protect the theater. On the night of the December reading, a small riot broke out involving several dozen people and youths who set fire to a car and garbage cans. It was "the most excitement we've ever had down here," says the socialist mayor.
. . . . Now that tempers have calmed, Mayor Bertrand says he is proud his town took a stand by refusing to cave in under pressure to call off the reading. Free speech is modern Europe's "foundation stone," he says. "For a long time we have not confirmed our convictions, so lots of people think they can contest them."
Something about the attitude of this mayor tugged at my memory, and I wondered if the residents of Saint-Genis-Pouilly descend from the Huguenots who fled into the mountains of the Swiss border (among many other places) in the 16th c. to escape persecution by the Catholic Church. Another town in that area is Le Chambon-sur-Lignon, which matter-of-factly sheltered thousands of Jewish children during WWII. In the documentary "Weapons of the Spirit," the people of Chambon repeatedly cited their Huguenot heritage when asked about their motivations. Like other dissident Protestant groups, the Huguenots sought religious freedom by emigrating to the New World in large numbers, had a deep distrust of state religion and state authority in general, and considered the Old Testament equal to the New as a source of Divine instruction.
I wasn't able to find out if that is indeed the heritage of Saint-Genis-Pouilly. But the good humor, the matter-of-fact refusal to be pushed around, and the physical and intellectual distance from the centers of urbane sophistry -- all remind me of the villagers of Chambon.
Then we have the man who guided the campaign against the Voltaire play, one Hafid Ouardiri, who is about as far from a Huguenot as you can get. The Protestant dissidents helped usher in the Enlightenment by precipitating a rupture between the Church and the State, which in turn set the stage for the concept of inalienable individual rights.
Mr. Ouardiri is going in the other direction:
Mr. Ouardiri, an Algerian-born former leftist radical, came to France in the 1960s and says he used to chant the 1968 student slogan, "It is forbidden to forbid." Now a devout Muslim, he says he champions "the need to forbid." Algeria and other Muslim countries, he says, were colonized by Europeans "nourished by Voltaire."
So are we still, I hope.
Judith | 03/11/06 at 12:23 PM | Categories: - Across the Pond
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.keshertalk.com/cgi-bin/mtb.cgi/4646
Blogs which link to A tale of two towns:
» New issue of Azure from Kesher Talk
Azure - the always-interesting Israei policy journal - has a new issue out much of which you can read for free online. Some highlights: A book review by Kesher Talk's own occasional contributor Benjamin Kerstein. (More here.) Uriyah Shavit claims... [Read More]
Tracked on October 23, 2006 06:59 AM













![[TypeKey Profile Page]](http://www.keshertalk.com/nav-commenters.gif)