« Dozens of Leak Investigations Under Way | Home | Soundtrack for a neocon revolution »
April 22, 2006
Details Details

Mary McCarthy, the CIA officer just fired for political leaking to the press turns out to be, how unsurprising!, a Clinton appointee, who worked under former National Security Advisor, Sandy Berger, well known for stealing classified documents himself during the time of the 9/11 commission.
She apparently failed not just one polygraph, but a series of them. And, AJ Strata points out that she may now be cooperating with the Justice Department, as she has not yet been charged with any crime and is not the subject of a Justice Department investigation.
Macsmind has a slightly different take, reporting that the investigation on McCarthy came as a result of a tip, by someone who may have received immunity.
Meanwhile, in the ultimate irony, the EU yesterday reported that they have been unable to find any secret prisons in Eastern Europe, the very story which McCarthy is charged with leaking unlawfully to Washington Post reporter, Dana Priest.
Investigations into reports that US agents shipped prisoners through European airports to secret detention centers have produced no evidence of illegal CIA activities, the European Union's antiterrorism coordinator said yesterday.What, one wonders, will happen to Ms. Priest's Pulitzer if the story was entirely fabricated, and Ms. Priest never bothered to research it, relying only on the leak and the anti-Bush media frenzy that would follow.The investigations also have not turned up any proof of secret renditions of terror suspects on EU territory, Gijs de Vries told a European Parliament committee investigating the allegations.
The European Parliament's probe and a similar one by the continent's leading human rights watchdog are looking into whether US intelligence agents interrogated Al Qaeda suspects at secret prisons in Eastern Europe and transported some on secret flights through Europe.
But so far investigators have not identified any human rights violations, despite more than 50 hours of testimony by human rights activists and individuals who said they were abducted by US intelligence agents, de Vries said.
''We've heard all kinds of allegations, impressions; we've heard also refutations. It's up to your committee to weigh if they are true. It does not appear to be proven beyond reasonable doubt," he said. ''There has not been, to my knowledge, evidence that these illegal renditions have taken place."
From this tidbit, Rick Moran and others, among them Macsmind, conclude that the "Secret Prisons" story may have been part of an internal CIA ruse to uncover leakers within the CIA.
Just One Minute provides a list of her political donations in 2004; McCarthy and her husband contributed $9500 to various democrats, $2000 a piece from husband and wife to Kerry, $5000 to the Ohio DNC and $500 to Barbara Mikulski.
And we all remember the crucial role of Ohio in the previous election, don't we.
Mary McCarthy also has links to Richard Clarke, whom she defended during the 9/11 hearings, as well as JOE WILSON, whom she served together with at the National Security Council under the African portfolio. AJ Strata demurs, thinking that the connection to WIlson so far looks thin.
She was also a member of the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), which she joined in August 2001. Fellow members include:
Zbigniew Brzezinski -- Counselor and Trustee, CSIS
General Wesley Clark USA (Ret.), Distinguished Senior Adviser
General Anthony Zinni USMC (Ret.), Distinguished Senior Adviser
The CSIS removed Mary McCarthy's biographical data from the web very shortly after it was cited on the web. It is cached here.
There is a question now as to her relationship with VIPS - Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity, who have been notable Bush critics, and some people suspect helped orchestrate the Plame Game. McCarthy was the former boss of Larry Johnson, a prominent member of VIPS, though he claims she was responsible for him leaving that position.
On that point, Macsmind, among others, notes that she worked in the IG's (Inspector General's) office of the CIA, which office "directly worked on the referral to the JD of the Valerie Plame Game." It's been a question for a long time who leaked the IG's referral to the Justice Department to Andrea Mitchell, causing a media frenzy with enough political pressure to set the Plame Game Investigation in motion.
UPDATE: In an absolutely hysterical, "soft light focus" look at Mary McCarthy, the NYTimes digs up all her bestest friends, connections from her time at the CSIS and presents us with their view of her.UPDATE: In an absolutely hysterical, "soft light focus" look at Mary McCarthy, the NYTimes digs up all her bestest friends, connections from her time at the CSIS and presents us with their view of her. NOT INCIDENTALLY, the director of CSIS, William Goodfellow, is the husband of Dana Priest. Oh how incestuous it all is!
CORRECTION: How embarrassing. I'd been working on this correction, then took a break to procrastinate, just as a commenter kindly informed me that my info about Goodfellow was incorrect. He is not an executive director at CSIS, but at CIP, which is the Center for International policy, otherwise known as Fidel Castro's favorite think tank. A commenter at my other blog has more info about CIP here. And Sweetness and Light has more info here.
But back to the NYTimes' expose friendly treatment of McCarthy.
We're talking about a person with great integrity who played by the book and, as far as I know, never deviated from the rules," said Steven Simon, a National Security Council aide in the Clinton administration who worked closely with Ms. McCarthy.So she only leaked because she was disenchanted or unhappy, because she is a good person with integrity, that's all right then.Others said it was possible that Ms. McCarthy, who began attending law school at night several years ago, made a campaign contribution to Senator John Kerry's presidential campaign in 2004 and had announced her intention to retire from C.I.A., had grown increasingly disenchanted with the often harsh and extra-legal methods adopted by the Bush administration for handling Al Qaeda prisoners and felt she had no alternative except to go to the press.
If in fact Ms. McCarthy was the leaker, Richard J. Kerr, a former C.I.A. deputy director, said, "I have no idea what her motive was, but there is a lot of dissension within the agency and it seems to be a rather unhappy place." Mr. Kerr called Ms. McCarthy "quite a good, substantive person on the issues I dealt with her on.
The end of the article can't be missed. Despite the fact that Ms. McCarthy has already admitted talking to reporters, her old pal, Larry Johnson, whose boss she used to be, is incredulous that this could be true. No, he reckons it was an hysterical confession from an innocent woman. The evil Porter Goss and his cabal done her wrong.
Government officials said that after Ms. McCarthy's polygraph examination showed the possibility of deception, the examiner confronted her and she disclosed having conversations with reporters.But some former C.I.A. employees who know Ms. McCarthy remain unconvinced, arguing that the pressure from Mr. Goss and others in the Bush administration to plug leaks may have led the agency to focus on an employee on the verge of retirement, whose work at the White House during the Clinton administration had long raised suspicions within the current administration.
"It looks to me like Mary is being used as a sacrificial lamb," said Larry Johnson, a former C.I.A. officer who worked for Ms. McCarthy in the agency's Latin America section.
What a weird defense! How does this help her? They've constructed a scenario where she only confessed because she couldn't stand the pressure, though she is innocent. Is that the kind of CIA agent we want operating at the top level of government.
Gosh! Perhaps those evil Bushies took her down to Guantanamo and pressured her to confess!
Previous Post on this issue: Dozens of Leak Investigations Under Way
Alcibiades | 04/22/06 at 03:16 PM | Categories: - The Fourth Estate
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.keshertalk.com/cgi-bin/mtb.cgi/4855
Comments
Kim Jong's Ill states:
"My Triumph is ERNEVERTABRUL!"
fntstc4 | April 22, 2006 09:53 PM
If she talked to reporters and gave away intelligence information she should be gone !
Paul | April 23, 2006 07:58 AM
It's all made rather more egregious because of the fact that she worked in the Office of the Inspector General, which office is in charge of internal investigations of alleged wrongdoing at the agency.
"The inspector general is routinely granted extraordinary access to secrets ordinarily not shared with others inside the CIA."
How is that for an abuse of the integrity of one's office.
Alcibiades | April 23, 2006 10:30 AM
I'm a bit confused about the above story, given the statements by MEPs today that the CIA were in fact carrying out illegal activities. Can someone explain?
Robin
Euro MPs damn CIA prison flights The CIA has run more than 1,000 flights within the European Union since 2001, often transporting terror suspects for questioning overseas, MEPs have said.
The MEPs began a probe after claims the US flew suspects to secret prisons in countries that regularly use torture.
The US admits some terror suspects were flown overseas for interrogation, but denies sending them for torture.
Report author Claudio Fava said many EU states had ignored the hundreds of CIA flights that had used their airports.
Mr Fava, an Italian socialist MEP, singled out Sweden, Italy and Bosnia, which is not an EU member, for particular criticism.
A string of former detainees have come forward with stories alleging kidnap and transport by the US for interrogation in third countries - so-called "extraordinary rendition".
Some have provided detailed accounts of alleged torture carried out in secret prisons outside EU or US jurisdiction.
'Hearsay'
Earlier this year the European human rights watchdog, the Council of Europe, made similar allegations, but these were dismissed by the US as hearsay.
The CIA has... clearly been responsible for kidnapping and illegally detaining alleged terrorists
Claudio Fava
Italian MEP
Unveiling his report, Mr Fava said European governments and intelligence agencies should have verified the purpose of the CIA flights.
"We just have to think about the use of the airspace and airports by [the] CIA: more than 1,000 flights run by the US secret services, often used directly for extraordinary renditions," he said.
He suggested that flight plans and airport logs meant it was hard to believe that many of the stopovers were simple refuelling missions.
"The CIA has, on several occasions, clearly been responsible for kidnapping and illegally detaining alleged terrorists on the territory of [EU] member states, as well as for extraordinary renditions," said Mr Fava.
He made specific reference to several alleged abductions, including the snatch in Milan of Egyptian cleric Abu Omar in 2003.
Italian authorities were highly likely to have known the details of Abu Omar's case, Mr Fava said.
Investigators used data from Eurocontrol, the EU's air safety agency, to examine records of thousands of flights.
'Strange routes'
Mr Fava described many of the flights as "quite suspect".
Among those highlighted was the flight transferring Khalid al-Masri, a Kuwaiti-born German national, who was seized in Macedonia and transported to Afghanistan in 2004.
That plane flew from Algeria to Majorca, Spain, then to Skopje, Macedonia, and onto Kabul via Baghdad, all within 48 hours.
"They are rather strange routes for flights to take. It is hard to imagine... those stopovers were simply for providing fuel," said Mr Fava.
Mr Masri has previously given details of his transfer to the European Parliament. He alleges he was seized in Macedonia, interrogated in Kabul and released into Albania.
New investigations
Mr Fava's committee spent more than three months interviewing top EU officials, magistrates, human rights activists and people who said they were abducted by the CIA.
Despite knowing that allowing rendition and possibly torture would breach a raft of European human rights treaties, Mr Fava said EU diplomats did nothing.
He singled out Italy, Sweden and Bosnia as governments he expected knew more than they made public about the flights.
Mr Fava's committee did not report on secret prisons, but he said members planned to visit countries such as Romania and Poland for further investigations later this year.
The CIA declined to comment on Mr Fava's findings.
Robin Stamler | April 26, 2006 05:02 PM
I'm not quite sure what point you are asking about, but I'll try to clarify.
It seems that some details of the story are true, there were these flights through Europe, etc. Other details are in dispute or unknown or provable. And politics abound.
Gijs De Vries, the person providing the testimony in the article I cited that came out earlier, is the EU's counter terror tsar.
Claudio Fava, socialist MEP for Italy (from Sicily) obviously weighs the same evidence differently.
It appears to depend on how much weight is put on the testimony of various witnesses. This appears to be an intermediary stage of the reporting, not a final stage, so we'll have to wait to see more. And come to a conclusion, subtracting all the European politics inevitably mixed up in it.
Still it wasn't McCarthy's purview to provide evidence, or merely corroborating evidence, to a journalist to expose an ongoing operation that would jeopardize our international relations in the Intelligence world.
Moreover, at the time she is supposed to have done this, she worked in the Office of the Inspector General, who is responsible for internal CIA investigations, among them for illegal leaks.
I hoped this helped.
Alcibiades | April 26, 2006 11:53 PM













![[TypeKey Profile Page]](http://www.keshertalk.com/nav-commenters.gif)