« Now that Passover is Over... | Home | China in the News »
April 20, 2006
United 93: Ready or not?
All entries on United 93 here.
I said a few weeks ago that "United 93" would become a litmus test for attitudes on fighting terrorism, that hawks would derive comfort and resolve from it and (the more extremist) doves would see it as a threat and seek to discredit it. (See this comment thread for examples of: 1. conspiracy-theorizing, 2. claims of insensitivity and exploitation, 3. fears that the film will fan war fervor, 4. sneering at heroism in general.)
The earliest effort to undercut the film's impact started with the genuine reaction of a few movie-goers exposed to a trailer they hadn't been expecting: "It's too soon!" "Are we ready?"
LA Times reviewer Patrick Goldstein counters with "What Took So Long?" This is a valuable defense of the movie from someone who is firmly against the Iraq War, but is honest about the hypocritical handwringing:
With emotions obviously still running high, it's no wonder some people seem so wary of Hollywood weighing in on the subject. But it seems disingenuous for those of us in the media, after having exhaustively explored every possible 9/11-related nook and cranny, to suddenly express outrage or brow-furrowing concern over the specter of Hollywood finally tackling the issue.This review is also good for more thoughtful statements from the director, who so far has come across as nothing but a mensch.
That link is from the conservative filmblog Libertas, which also quotes at length an early review from Hollywood Elsewhere, and adds:
Of course, the Main Stream Media is now scratching its head, wondering whether America is properly ‘ready’ for movies about 9/11. Again, it’s odd that this debate didn’t accompany Michael Moore’s film, or the recent V For Vendetta (as obvious a War on Terror metaphor as we’ve seen), but now that realistic depictions of the War on Terror are being presented, suddenly some people are very worried about the public’s ability to ‘handle’ (i.e., absorb on their own) what’s coming at them.Read the whole thing, and read the comments for a few affirmations that "yes, we're ready." For example:
I have to see this movie. I don’t want to, but I NEED to. I need to relive the same level of emotion (or something close to it) I felt in the weeks after 9/11.Why?
Because we’re about to deal with Iran soon. We need to be READY to deal with the consequences of that. Either Iran is going to eventually use their new found nukes against us, or we’re going to use something near that level on them. And then the real fun begins as the Muslim world (and the rest of the world) reacts.
Flight 93 can put me (dunno about others) back emotionally where I need to be, to remind me what it is we’re involved in. It’s too easy to forget.
Lastly, why would I need to be reminded about this? What can I do? Plenty.
-Vote
-Voice my opinion to others I wouldn’t typically say anything to.
-Get involved as a volunteer in a local political race (something I’ve NEVER done).
-MAKE FILMS (Internet distribution through Youtube.com or other places now makes this possible)It’s a start. But to really begin, you’ve got to be motivated. Flight 93 can help me with that right there.
Two comments from another movie blog:
I was within a mile from the Towers when it all went down on 9/11 and saw a lot of what happened to the one tower I used to be able to see from my apartment roof. I was in shock for a number of days and it took a few weeks to get used to the towers not looming over my neighborhood, but I'm really looking forward to seeing United 93 because it actually deals with the flight and people we know the least about, those that didn't even go near the towers. I think if it dealt with the planes that crashed into the towers or the people working there who died, it might be tough, but this seems like it could be a solid reality-based drama that would make a good film.I really don't think New Yorkers are nearly as sensitive as people are trying to give us credit for. 9/11 was a tragedy but it's over four years ago and I'd expect that those who didn't lose immediate family and friends barely even think about it except when it's brought up, and even then (and I can only speak for myself), it's thought of a tragedy that never should have happened...but also as something that we endured and got over.
I think America needs a movie like United 93. It's been almost five years since any major media outlet has displayed footage that was taken on 9/11. I'm not suggesting that Americans should dwell on the terror of that day...but when a modern, visual society such as ours chooses not to show images of the planes hitting the towers or the terror on people's faces as they realized that people were jumping 100 stories to their death to escape the evil that had been inflicted on them, it's easy to see why wiretapping terrorists is actually controversial.
Judith | 04/20/06 at 06:40 PM | Categories: - Power to the People
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.keshertalk.com/cgi-bin/mtb.cgi/4848
Blogs which link to United 93: Ready or not?:
» United 93: good cop, bad cop from Kesher Talk
All entries on United 93 here. The premier of United 93 has come and gone, and the movie opens tomorrow. The victims' families all agreed to the making of the film, and many are positive about the results. My posts... [Read More]
Tracked on April 27, 2006 05:35 PM
» United 93: Mars and Venus from Kesher Talk
All United 93 entries here. Last week I posted some examples of the wildly varying reactions to United 93. I had predicted that the fault line would be one's understanding of the terrorist threat: People who believe we need... [Read More]
Tracked on April 29, 2006 02:24 AM
Comments
Good call, Judith. Only people who do not believe (or who want to not believe) that Islamic fascism is at war with the West could in complete confidence counsel that it is "too soon" for "Flight 93".
Jeremayakovka | April 20, 2006 07:16 PM


![[TypeKey Profile Page]](http://www.keshertalk.com/nav-commenters.gif)












