« 9-11: Kesher Talk posts about the film United 93 | Home | Hudson Institute Conference on the future of the UN »
September 10, 2006
Ellul 17: Completely unprepared on 9-11
All 9-11 entries here.
Teshuva contemplations every day until Yom Kippur here. Each entry also contains an mp3 of a Jewish song related to the theme of the post. Genres range from Iraqi folk musicians to the Klezmatics.
Rabbi Amy Scheinerman's guide to teshuvah using the text of Psalm 27 focuses this week on Rejection.
From Live at Stubbs, Matisyahu sings about bewilderment and lack of control in "King without a Crown"
Two years ago I quoted a lot from Rabbi Alan Lew's excellent guide to the Yamim Noraim, This is Real and You are Completely Unprepared, which conveys the underlying psychic symbolic structure of the Yamim Noraim better than anything else I have read. (Here is an excerpt from the book, and parts of it appear in sermons collected at his synagogue's website, all of which are worth reading.)
As we approach the anniversary of the Islamist attacks on America, a beautiful day in September, a day which no one who perished in the World Trade Center Towers, or the surrounding streets, or any of the airplanes, or the Pentagon, expected to be their last . . . . Rabbi Lew's theme of being unprepared assumes a poignant relevance.
On Yom Kippur we wear an imitation shroud, for several reasons. One is to emphasize that this day, or any day, may be our last, and therefore the confessions we make today should be treated as deathbed confessions - are your moral accounts up-to-date? Have you hugged your loved ones today?
But as Rabbi Lew explains, no matter how prepared we think we are . . . . on a deeper level, we are not in control:
The title [of his book] to me describes the essential transformation that is part of the holidays. The phrase "completely unprepared" really strikes a deep chord. It names something deep and pervasive in the human psyche. Although we're not often in touch with this feeling, deep down we all feel unprepared. If we look at our lives honestly, the events that really shape us, that really make us who we are, are the events we didn't prepare for, or we couldn't prepare for, like a serious illness, the loss of a loved one, the failure of a relationship, or God forbid the loss of a child. Or suddenly a child appears surprisingly, or we fall in love. These are the things that really shape our lives.We spend most of our lives preparing like crazy--we prepare for our professional lives, we prepare for our health by doing exercise, we do self-improvement, we always anticipate tomorrow, but the mounting evidence is that what we anticipate almost never occurs tomorrow. We live life like a kind of Maginot line--the line of defense that the French built to ward off the Germans and they ended up coming from a completely different direction. Our life is like that--it comes at us from a different direction than we think it's going to. It circumvents all our defenses and leaves us feeling very unprepared.
All of this is at the heart of the High Holiday journey, this journey of the soul that we go through every year at this time. It's built into the liturgy: the service that we do on Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur is taken almost word for word from the prayer service that went along with the public fast. Public fast was something practiced during Rabbinic times, the time of the Talmud, for public emergencies, the kind of things you couldn't prepare for--drought, a ship lost at sea, a city under siege. It's a liturgy for a spiritual emergency, for an urgent desperate matter you can't prepare for. The shofar is like the ancient alarm--it was something that we blew at a really desperate, urgent time.
Judith | 09/10/06 at 11:24 PM | Categories: - Yamim Noraim
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.keshertalk.com/cgi-bin/mtb.cgi/5502
Blogs which link to Ellul 17: Completely unprepared on 9-11:
» Ellul 17: Completely unprepared on 9-11 from Kesher Talk
Teshuva contemplations every day until Yom Kippur here. You can also find the link on the sidebar under "Yamim Noraim." Rabbi Amy Scheinerman's guide to teshuvah using the text of Psalm 27 focuses this week on Regret. From Live... [Read More]
Tracked on September 10, 2006 05:33 PM
» Ellul 18 : Rise up to your higher power from Kesher Talk
All 9-11 entries here. Teshuva contemplations every day until Yom Kippur here. Each entry includes an mp3 of a Jewish song related to the theme. Genres range from Iraqi folk musicians to Matisyahu. You can also find the link on... [Read More]
Tracked on September 11, 2006 02:26 AM
Comments
That sermon was wonderful. I felt something like it when I walked into shul on Rosh Hashanah and simply the melody for the day cultivated a sense of awe. Rabbi Goodman of Neve Shalom had a story about Rosh Hashanah and the "dome of truth" which I believe has not transferred to the new website.
4jkb4ia | September 11, 2006 11:04 AM













![[TypeKey Profile Page]](http://www.keshertalk.com/nav-commenters.gif)