About Kesher Talk


NPJrecipe-sidead.jpg

Recent Comments

  • Fat Man [TypeKey Profile Page] on Che Moods : ""In plain truth, he hardly cared for them at all." And Che? He didn't give...."

« Plane crashes into 50-story apartment building in NYC | Home | Avoiding Political Embarrassment the Columbia University Way »

October 11, 2006

Vulnerable in Manhattan

I am sitting in my apartment on the 25th floor of a 44-story high rise apartment building near Columbus Circle. It is raining, grey and gloomy. I can see west from my windows, but it is too far away to see smoke or anything from the crash.

My apartment faces another tall building, but it is diagonally open to the northwest, and a plane could fly into the corner of my building and ignite my apartment.

I usually feel safe in this 24-hour doorman building. This spring I was emailing with another blogger who lives in another large city, who asked me if I felt safe posting the Mohammed cartoons from Denmark. His wife didn't want him to post them on his blog. I wrote that it would be very difficult for assassins to get into my apartment, but they could gun me down if they wanted to on the busy street outside my building. He replied that he lives in a fairly secluded suburban neighborhood. It would be easy for someone to find out where both of us live, but paradoxically - considering the reputation of big cities vs. the suburbs - he is more vulnerable that I am. (Of course I am more protected than many urbanites who don't live in highrise doorman buildings, and if I worked outside my home I might be in an office that isn't well-protected. Like the huge office building across the street wherein someone I had lunch with last week has his office.)

This plane crash was an accident, but it illustrates how easy it would be for terrorists to fly a small plane into, say, the UN, which is only a 45 min. walk from the Bellaire. Or the new Apple store. (Don't laugh - read the story.) My building - like the Bellaire - is one of dozens of highrises which make up the Manhattan skyline, and none are targets in themselves. But random plane crashes could be NYC's version of suicide bombings in Israel: impossible to predict or to stop, at least until our intelligence apparatus caught up. (We could also be subjected to street-level suicide attacks but, since none have taken place so far, I'm going to assume that a combination of local, state, national, and international crime-fighting and intelligence agencies are doing their job, rather than assume that none have been attempted.)

Although this crash was an accident, I fear that terrorists now see how easy it was for a small plane to fly undetected into a Manhattan building. Or into any large urban building anywhere.

Or simply plummet into a large urban gathering place. I live 15 blocks from Times Square. On New Year's Eve and the 4th of July I worry. The police cordons and crowd control seem very thorough, but I can't believe that all backpacks are searched. On New Year's Eve, everyone wears bulky clothing against the cold, and anyone could be wearing a bomb belt. Maybe the police dogs would sniff them all out. But no one could prevent a plane crash like the one today. How about a plane crash with a large bomb on board?

Then there are the subways. It's funny what different people will obsess on. Suspicious packages? Eh. Since reading about this scenario, I worry about a small nuke in the NY harbor causing a tsunami that swamps the city. All the tunnels and subways would be flooded. Imagine being underground. Your subway train suddenly screeches to a halt. Perhaps the conductor has time to say something about evacuating, then the wave hits, people frantically try to claw their way out of the car but unless you are in the station there is no way to get above the rising water, and maybe not even then.

Well, we can all think of ten more scenarios without trying. This stuff doesn't keep me up at night, but it is always at the edge of my consciousness. But in that respect am I different from anyone else in today's world?

UPADATE: The speed and precision of the response by NYC police and firefighters locally, and the FAA and NORAD nationally, is somewhat comforting.

Judith | 10/11/06 at 07:55 PM | Categories: NYC

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.keshertalk.com/cgi-bin/mtb.cgi/5674

Blogs which link to Vulnerable in Manhattan:

» NYC: Yankee Pitcher Dies in Aircraft Crash into Building from Pajamas Media
News New York Yankee pitcher Cory Lidle confirmed as the pilot; dies in the crash Harold Vine, a witness to the crash said he saw a plane lose power and strike the building. "The man was going down and he... [Read More]

Tracked on October 11, 2006 06:17 PM

» Roll, Pitch, Yawn from Jeremayakovka
Judith, how lives within a couple of miles of the accident, has two of the most reflective posts I've seen yet. I certainly appreciate them, having grown up just yards from the scene of the accident. [Read More]

Tracked on October 12, 2006 01:55 AM

Comments

how times have changed. On 9/11 when my brother IM'd me to tell me that a plane flew into one of the trade towers I assumed that it was an accident. When I found out today's crash I had assumed it was Terror attack

Sammy Benoit | October 11, 2006 08:50 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style and URL links.
My spam filter rejects any word containing "sex" and "poker" - use asterisks like so: "p*ker")