About Kesher Talk

  • "Kesher" means "connection" in Hebrew. The banner image is the mosaic floor of a 6th c. synagogue in Jericho, showing a menorah flanked by a shofar and lulav; the inscription reads "Shalom Al Yisrael." (This synagogue was destroyed by Arab vandals a few years ago. The condition of the mosaic floor is unknown.)
  • Contributors:
  • Judith Weiss
    admin-at-keshertalk-dot-com
  • Van Wallach
    mission76tx-at-yahoo-dot-com


« More home movies from Israel | Home | Harridan of the Sea »

January 17, 2007

Blogosphere Roundup on Psychology Today's "Ideological Animal" Article

I posted an item last week regarding Psychology Today's "The Ideological Animal," an article in the current issue that purports to explain those of us who made the post-9/11 political shift from left to right (or somewhere in between). Many members of the 9/11 Neocons, the discussion group I started, as well as the group founded and moderated by Kesher Talk editor Judith Weiss, the Liberal Hawks, comprise this burgeoning political trend.

Unfortunately, while treating my story fairly, I felt that the Psychology Today article rehashed many of the same old stereotypes portraying conservatives as neanderthals and liberals as enlightened beings. Its central thesis, that an irrational fear of death is what motivates the movement towards conservatism, further adds to the article's questionable conclusions.

This week, the blogosphere weighs in on the subject with a number of interesting posts. Some of them are written by Liberal Hawk bloggers and in particular, those in the mental health professions. The latter make up a Pajamas Media Sanity Squad podcast on the subject. And predictably, liberal bloggers have used the results of the PT article to confirm their own preconceived notions about conservatives. The following is a roundup of related links thus far:

This week's PJM Sanity Squad podcast, hosted by Shrinkwrapped, Neo-Neocon, Dr. Sanity and Siggy, focuses "On Fear." These four give the PT article a sound thrashing.

Shrinkwrapped on The Use and Mis-Use of Psychology

Fausta's blog on Psy Today's Ideological Animal .

Andrew Sullivan find the PT study "provocative" in "Fear and Politics."

Red State Kids parodies the PT article with "Want Conservative Minded Kids? Then Scare Them to Death."

Radio Nerd on "Why Conservatives are the True Bedwetters."

Yave Begnet questions the "Fear of Death" thesis.

Flame Skirt finds that that PT article reinforces his/her notions about "how fear and ignorance has changed this country" (presumably since 9/11).

Raising Kaine, which bills itself as "The Voice of Progressive Virginia" invokes Karl Rove conspiracies in discussing "Liberals and Conservatives at Age 3."

In addition, there are several posts at my own blog, CinnamonStillwell.blogspot.com, on the subject. Click here, here, here and here.

Beyond the blogosphere, Washington Post staff writer Peter Carlson references the PT article in "Delving Into Political Minds."

I've omitted several blogs that only linked to, rather than commenting on, the PT article. But if there's anything significant I've missed, feel free to post the links in the comments section. I'll be adding more links as they arise.

Update: Iron Shrink presents "A Methodology Critique in Defense of Those Wascally Wepublicans" (hat tip Fausta).

Dissecting Leftism opines on "Another Misleading Analysis of Conservatism By Leftist Psychologists." Blogger John Ray is one of the authors whose research was cited in the Jost study, which is referenced in the PT article.

Update II: Conservative radio talk show host Sean Hannity discussed the PT article during today's (1/18) show. He mostly focused on "liberals vs. conservatives" stereotypes and found the article to be extremely skewed in its approach.

Update III: Michelle Malkin weighs in briefly with "Debunking the 'conservatives are crazy' study" (hat tip Jeremaykovka).

Noel Sheppard at Newsbusters notes that "Psychology Today Rips Conservatives While Praising Liberals."

Update IV: Day by Day, a popular online (conservative-leaning) comic strip, gets in a dig at the PT article in today's (1/19) strip.

Update V: Blogger, friend and fellow Kesher Talk contributor (and 9/11 Neocon/Libhawk) Asher Abrams has posted an "Open Letter to Jay Dixit" at his blog, Dreams Into Lightning. He too was interviewed for the article and he makes a very good point: "...in an entire article devoted to what you call the '9/11 effect,' there is not a single direct reference to the terrorist attacks that killed almost 3,000 Americans."

Update VI: The Daily Duck weighs in on the "The Scandal of the Leftist Mind."

Blog-friend, fellow post-9/11 political traveler and Sanity Squad co-host Neo-neocon lends her voice to the discussion in "The psychology of Psychology Today (about those liberals and conservatives)." Neo was interviewed for the PT article too, but didn't make the cut because, she suspects, her story didn't fit the "fear as motivator" thesis being pushed by the author.

Update VII: Right As Usual responds to the PT article with "I Feel a Rant Comin' On."

Fausta chimes in again with "Neo-neocon Posts About the Psychology of Psychology Today."

Update VIII: David Yeagley reflects on the PT article and post-9/11 political transformation at BadEagle.com. It seems Mike McConnell discussed the subject on his Cincinnati radio show last weekend.

Cross-posted at CinnamonStillwell.blogspot.com.


Cinnamon | 01/17/07 at 07:22 PM | Categories: - Around the blogosphere

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.keshertalk.com/cgi-bin/mtb.cgi/6056

Comments

You know, liberals cling to that FDR speech about "nothing to fear except fear itself" as if it was part of the Sermon on the Mount, but they forget that he was telling Americans not to be afraid to fight.

Andrea Harris [TypeKey Profile Page] | January 18, 2007 06:51 AM

Fausta [TypeKey Profile Page] | January 18, 2007 04:31 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style and URL links.
My spam filter rejects any word containing "sex" and "poker" - use asterisks like so: "p*ker")

CURRENT MOON
lunar phases