About Kesher Talk


NPJrecipe-sidead.jpg

Recent Comments

  • Fat Man [TypeKey Profile Page] on Che Moods : ""In plain truth, he hardly cared for them at all." And Che? He didn't give...."

« 9-11 around the blogosphere (will be updated throughout the day) | Home | Unetaneh Tokef »

September 11, 2007

My 9-11 story

On Tuesday, September 11, 2001, I was working from home on an instructional design project. I got up late and moseyed over to my computer in the office.

I glanced at the local paper, the mediocre Austin-American Statesman, but it had hit my doorstep before 8 AM New York time. And I didn't have a TV (still don't); I had gotten used to getting my news by listening to NPR's "All Things Considered" at 4 PM.

So I didn't know about the attacks until a friend called me about 11 AM to inform me that the Tuesday evening class we were taking at our synagogue had been cancelled, "because of what happened."

"What happened?" I asked.

"You don't know?" She said in hushed tones. And then proceeded to explain to me.

After a few minutes I said, "This is horrible of course, and maybe it isn't right for me to say this right now, but in a way I'm kind of relieved. Now maybe some of the terrorism and antisemitism that's been going on, will get people's attention and be addressed."

"We don't know yet for sure who did it." She said quickly.

"Yes we do." I said.

How come I was the only person I know, who knew immediately that it was Al Queda?

First of all, politically, I was open to the possibility that Islamist terrorists would attack America. Although most of my friends were "progressives", I was not of them, on many issues. I had been an anarcho-capitalist in college in the early 1970s, and as I matured I moderated my libertarianism into a "economically libertarian socially liberal" position which also supported such common social goods as, say, museums and libraries and (market-based) environmental laws. (Almost identical to Glenn Reynold's politics today.)

At the same time, I had the smug liberal disdain for conservatives, who I thought were socially repressive and just as bad as big-government liberals, but in the other direction. I was very concerned with abortion remaining legal (still am). I voted for Al Gore in 2000, and was outraged that George Bush won the subsequent vote parsing.

So I already had a skeptical stance toward liberal shibboleths and was used to not following the crowd, which made it possible to adjust my worldview without severe psychological dislocation.

I had read an article about Islam in 1985, in The Whole Earth Review, which at the time was a very interesting journal which always had thought-provoking articles on obscure social and technical topics. Only WER would write 20 years ago about the growth of Islam in the 3rd World and say "You better pay attention to this." I didn't learn more about Islam but I did file that away in the back of my mind.

I was a news junkie. I was already getting some of my news from the internet, mostly reading newspapers online, and email lists which circulated various bits of news, for example Phil Agre's Red Rock Eater News Service which sent out long lists of interesting news links about 3 times a week. (This would probably have morphed into a blog a year later, if he had kept it up).

I had been following Israel news since the intifada began, at Rosh Hashanah in 2000. And watched with horror as, after 10 years of slowly increasing international acceptance of Israel as a normal country, the leftist antisemitism of the 1970's began to resurge. The infamous 2001 UN Durban conference on "racism," which was hijacked by Palestinian extremists and because a hate-Israel rally, had just ended the week before. Liberal Jews were reeling from the shock. Some were already blaming themselves. Phil Agre's links showed him turning from from a political fellow traveler of mine into a virulent anti-Israel campus academic. (Which he probably was already, but the subject didn't come up.)

I began to participate in online forums where I read much the same. I was desperate to refute the ignorance and deliberate smearing and scapegoating. I continued to be shocked by Jewish political masochism. I began to pull away from my "progressive" friends and seek out people who got what was happening. It was too painful otherwise.

As a feminist, I had been following the treatment of women under the Taliban. Because I knew about the Taliban, I knew about Al Queda. And because I knew about anti-Israel terrorism, I knew about Al Queda.

On September 9th, 2001, Ahmed Massood had been assasinated by Al Queda, which put them in the news right before the 9-11 attacks.

So I knew who it was.

Right after my friend called I turned on NPR and followed their coverage. I had to return something at Best Buy, so I went there that afternoon and I stood watching replays on their wide-screen TVs for 3 hours.

That evening NPR had a call-in show, with a couple of pundits. If anyone tells you that leftist crowing about how "we got what we deserved" only developed in the following months, I am here to tell you that's not true. Less than 24 hours after the attacks, the breast-beating and gloating and rationalizations (and blaming Israel) had already begun on NPR, both from the pundits and the callers. I recall only one caller who objected, and the pundits verbally patted him on the head.

I redoubled my efforts on the forums and email lists.

I had been planning to move to New York that fall. I put it off till spring. Around the time I moved to NYC, I discovered blogs. The first ones I read were Meryl Yourish, Winds of Change, Instapundit, Kesher Talk, and LGF. (That was back when LGF posts got about 10 comments each.) I still read them. That summer the founder of Kesher Talk invited me to co-blog and eventually had to stop posting for job reasons, and gave me the blog.

So here I am, six years later, doing my part on a blog instead of newspaper forums.

Judith | 09/11/07 at 07:28 PM | Categories: - 9-11 and its ilk

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.keshertalk.com/cgi-bin/mtb.cgi/6598

Comments

Yehudit:

Here we are. six years later, warning of the mortal dangers of Islamic terrorists, and Jew-hatred—and Al Gore is fighting the, um, weather.

Robert Avrech | September 11, 2007 01:35 PM

What I noticed in the hours and days afterward was the denial, as in the inability to accept that the world had undergone a major change. People were enjoying their Holiday From History so much, they tried to treat this like a natural disaster that they could commiserate on and walk away from. Among other things, this denial led straight to the “Truther” movement (speaking of anti-Semitism). Mostly what I think it has created is an unwillingness to take action. Those who oppose the various actions in the War on Terror don’t seem to have any ideas or suggestion of what we should do instead – except to run home and hide. They call these world-shattering events a “bumper sticker slogan”. Whatever errors Bush may have made in the last few years, (this from a conservative Republican), you have to give him credit for actually trying to do something.

Hoosier David | September 11, 2007 11:42 PM

Shalom Judith and keep up your good work !

Paul | September 12, 2007 06:13 AM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style and URL links.
My spam filter rejects any word containing "sex" and "poker" - use asterisks like so: "p*ker")